The Court upheld the suspension and shutdown decision for national security but overlooked evidence that it was intended to paralyze protests, block communication, and facilitate attacks on demonstrators. This conclusion was supported by human rights reports. The Court also erred in accepting the security argument, despite proof that prisons were breached and police stations were attacked. The shutdown caused significant economic losses, estimated at $90 million, and deviated from both international human rights standards and the Egyptian Constitution, setting a binding precedent.