由此 A A CACC447/2010 B B IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF APPEAL (Appellate Jurisdiction) CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 447 OF 2010 (ON APPEAL FROM DCCC NO. 488 OF 2010) C D E --------------------------- F G E G HKSAR I D F BETWEEN H C Respondent H I and J J CHAN HOI TAT (陳凱達) Applicant K K --------------------------L L Before : Hon Cheung and Hartmann JJA and Barnes J in Court M N Dates of Hearing : 27 September 2011 M Date of Judgment: 27 September 2011 N Date of Handing Down Reasons for Judgment : 18 October 2011 O O ------------------------------------------------------REASONS FOR JUDGMENT ------------------------------------------------------- P Q P Q Hon Barnes J (giving the Judgment of the Court): R R Introduction S S 1. T The applicant appeared before HH Judge Geiser in the District Court and was convicted, after trial, of one count of aiding, abetting, T U U V V