由此 - 45 - A B But I am not sure that I can go further and hold on the balance of probability that there has been recklessness. C D E IV. 181. A B C D CONCLUSION The Plaintiffs have succeeded in establishing defamation. E ATOL’s defence of qualified privilege fails. There will be an award of F G H I general damages of $1 million in favour of ARY and of $150,000 each to ARY Traders and Digital UK. 182. F G There will be an Order Nisi that ATOL pay the Plaintiffs’ costs to be taxed if not agreed. H I J J K K L L M M N (A. T. Reyes) Judge of the Court of First Instance High Court N O O P P Q R Mr Paul Carolan, instructed by Messrs Haldanes, for the Plaintiffs Mr Leo Remedios, instructed by Messrs Yuen & Partners, for the 1st Defendant Q R S S T T U U V V