Lee Hsien Loong v Leong Sze Hian
[2021] SGHC 66
of our constitution; and the law of defamation is increasingly to
be seen as an aspect of it. It is no more than an ordinary
incident of the common law’s incremental method that familiar
notions such as abuse of process should be fashioned for its
service.
73
What is immediately apparent from Lait is the observation that the
balance to be struck between public interest and private rights is to be seen as a
function of the constitution. This is a significant distinction which again is not
applicable in the Singapore context – the United Kingdom’s unwritten
constitution does not operate in quite the same manner that Singapore’s
Constitution does. For one, Singapore’s Constitution is expressly stated as being
the supreme law of the land, whereas the United Kingdom’s common law and/or
unwritten constitution does not expressly provide so.
74
Moreover, Lait makes clear the reliance Jameel places on the
requirement of proportionality under the English CPR, as well as the Article 10
right to freedom of expression under the European Convention on Human
Rights. Once again, these instruments do not have direct cognates in Singapore,
even if some of the principles invoked may, depending on the facts, be
applicable. What is more significant, however, is that there is clear Court of
Appeal authority in Review Publishing (at [269] to [271]) indicating that it is
for Parliament to strike the balance between freedom of expression and the
constraints placed upon it by the law of defamation. My analysis above from
[54] to [57] would thus apply even if I were amenable to the exhortation in Lait
that the balance to be struck between public interest and private right is “a
function of our constitution”.
75
In sum, what can be gleaned from the decision in Lait is that the
substantive underlying factors behind the approach adopted in England include
instruments which have no precise equivalent in Singapore. Lait also involved
41
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents