- 15 A
B
A
34.
I appreciate that many online-only media (and their audience)
B
may desire strongly that such media should enjoy access in order to cover
C
C
the Chief Executive Election. But I cannot see how I can assume the
D
E
function of making policy and by the mandatory injunction sought by the
Applicant here require the Secretary and the Director to give access to a
D
E
certain class of such journalists and effectively to transfer their
F
gate-keeping function entirely to the Applicant.
G
G
35.
H
I
F
Accordingly, having regard to all the circumstances
including the nature of the injunction sought, the proper separation of the
courts from executive functions, the lack of a high degree of assurance
H
I
that the interim injunction sought would be found at trial to have been
J
K
rightly granted, the lateness of the application, and the concern for
maintenance of security and order at the Chief Executive Election,
J
K
I dismiss the application for interim injunction.
L
L
M
M
N
O
(Godfrey Lam)
Judge of the Court of First Instance
High Court
P
Q
R
N
O
P
Mr Johannes Chan SC and Ms Alison Choy, instructed by L & L Lawyers,
for the Applicant
Mr Victor Dawes SC and Mr Johnny Ma, instructed by Department of
Justice, for the Putative Respondents
Q
R
S
S
T
T
U
U
V
V