69
from Harold Feld, et al., Public Knowledge to Marlene H.
Dortch, FCC, at 10, GN Dkt. Nos. 14-28 & 10-127 (Dec. 19,
2014) (“Public Knowledge 12/19 Letter”). Commenters drew
the Commission’s attention to its recognition in 2007 that
“mobile broadband available with a standard mobile phone of
the time ‘enable[d] users to access a limited selection of
websites’ and primarily offered extremely limited
functionality such as email.” Id. (citing 2007 Wireless Order,
22 FCC Rcd. at 5906 ¶ 11 & n.43). Because of those
limitations, “[i]ndependent ‘app stores’ that allow for
seamless downloading and integration of standalone
applications [e.g., VoIP applications] into the customer’s
handset did not exist” in 2007. Id.
The Commission also noted that, today, mobile
broadband is dramatically faster: the average network
connection speed “exploded” in just three years, going from
an average connection speed of 709 kilobytes per second
(kbps) in 2010 to an average speed of 2,058 kbps for all
devices and 9,942 kbps for smartphones by 2013. 2015 Open
Internet Order, 30 FCC Rcd. at 5636 ¶ 89 & n.170. Partly as
a result, access to the internet and applications on one’s
mobile phone is no longer confined to a small number of
functions. Rather, “there has been substantial growth” even
since 2010—far more so since 2007—“in the digital app
economy . . . and VoIP” in particular. Id. at 5626 ¶ 76.
In addition, the Commission cited a letter which
explained that, because VoIP applications (such as FaceTime
on Apple devices and Google Hangouts on Android devices)
now come “bundled with the primary operating systems
available in every smartphone,” they are no longer “rare and
clearly functionally distinct” as they were in 2007. Letter
from Michael Calabrese, Open Technology Institute, et al., to
Marlene H. Dortch, FCC, at 6, GN Dkt. Nos. 14-28 & 10-127
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents