“One of Morocco’s most famous journalists is behind bars because of what he wrote about
public officials and state institutions,” said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East and North Africa
director at Human Rights Watch. “That is plain wrong – whatever one may think of his
columns.”
The Casablanca Court of Appeals on October 24, 2011, upheld the prison term against Nini,
whose column in the privately owned newspaper he directs, al-Masa’ (The Evening), is one of
the most widely read columns in Morocco.
The National Brigade of the Judicial Police (la Brigade nationale de police judiciaire, BNPJ)
summoned Nini for questioning on April 26, releasing him later the same day. On April 28, the
police summoned him again and obtained an order to detain him for 96 hours. The interrogation
focused on the content of his columns in al-Masa’, according to his signed statement and his
lawyers.
On May 1, the authorities brought Nini before the Casablanca prosecutor, who notified him he
faced charges of “gravely offending” public officials (article 263 of the penal code), accusing
public officials of violating the law without providing proof (article 264), and insulting the
judiciary or discrediting its rulings or attempting to influence the courts (article 266).
From the earliest phases of the case, the court rejected numerous motions by Nini’s lawyers to
release him provisionally pending a definitive verdict.
On June 9, the Casablanca Court of First Instance convicted Nini on all three charges and
sentenced him to one year in prison and a fine of 1,000 dirhams (US$120). The verdict and
sentence were both upheld on appeal.
The written verdict of the first-instance trial (misdemeanor case 11/10/3245, ruling 4675) lists
nine columns by Nini, all published in March or April. The verdict says that Nini confirmed that
he wrote them. In his defense, Nini told the court that some of the information in the articles
came from credible sources whose identity he could not disclose. Other parts of the articles, he
said, amounted to his own analysis and opinions regarding daily events. Nini denied in court that
his writings showed malice toward anyone or contempt for court rulings or a desire to influence
them.
The columns by Nini that are mentioned in the verdict include one attacking Abdellatif
Hammouchi for allegedly abusing his authority as head of the General Directorate of Territorial
Surveillance, a domestic intelligence agency widely known as the DST (the initials of its former
name in French, Direction de la surveillance du territoire). The column, a French translation of
which is online at http://www.droitetjustice.org/article_show.php?id=1592&ids=12, appeared in
al-Masa’ on April 18, eight days before the police first summoned Nini. The court, in its verdict,
also cites an article in which it says that Nini, without providing the necessary proof, accused
Hassan Aourid of enriching himself while he was governor of the Meknes-Tafilalet region.
Nini’s daily column “Chouf Tchouf” (a colloquial expression meaning, “Look and see”)
frequently targets what he views as acts of injustice, repression, and corruption for which he