Case: 12-57302, 05/18/2015, ID: 9540348, DktEntry: 197-1, Page 41 of 42
GARCIA V. GOOGLE
41
works. Id. at 487. Publishers warned that “‘devastating’
consequences,” including massive damages awards, would
result if the Court were to hold for the freelancers. Id. at 504.
The Court nonetheless held for the freelancers, turning back
the parade of horribles deployed by the publishers. The Court
explained that there are “numerous models for distributing
copyrighted works and remunerating authors for their
distribution.” Id. at 504–05. Tasini is a powerful reminder
that movie producers, publishers and distributors will always
claim that the sky is falling in cases that might recognize an
individual contributor’s copyright interest in material he
created.2 They will always say, as Google says here, that
holding in the contributor’s favor will make “Swiss cheese”
of copyrights. Maj. Op. 20.
But under our copyright law, the creators of original,
copyrightable material automatically acquire a copyright
interest in the material as soon as it is fixed. There’s no
exception for material created during production of a film or
other composite work. When modern works, such as films or
plays, are produced, contributors will often create separate,
copyrightable works as part of the process. Our copyright
law says that the copyright interests in this material vest
2
Ditto in Community for Creative Non-Violence v. Reid, 490 U.S. 730
(1989), which concerned the scope of a “work made for hire.” Id. at 738.
Amici representing, among others, publishers and technology companies
advocated for a broad definition of “employee.” They predicted “everincreasing interference with the dissemination of creative works” if the
Court didn’t adopt their definition of “employee.” Brief of the Computer
& Business Equipment Manufacturers’ Ass’n et al. in Support of
Petitioners at 4–5, Cmty. for Creative Non-Violence v. Reid, 490 U.S. 730
(1989) (No. 88-293). But the Court adopted the narrower definition of
“employee” used in agency law. Reid, 490 U.S. at 750–51. It appears that
creative works have been disseminating just fine in spite of Reid.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents