由此 - 38 - A B 146. Mr. Farah of the Washington Post, for instance, posted an online comment referring to the Article. This suggests that he had at least C A B C accessed and most probably downloaded the same. D D E 147. Further, among the documents in the bundle are e-mails dated E 22 April 2006 from Mr. Benish Memon and Mr. François Thiellet F G respectively, alerting their friend Mr. Salman Iqbal to the spread of the Article by a Mr. Tariq Muhammad. Mr. Muhammad (possibly a fictitious F G name) downloaded the Article and sent e-mails attaching the same to H various persons with the TV broadcast industry. I I 148. J Nor must I be taken to accept Mr. Remedios’ contention that there has been no publication in Hong Kong. 149. M J K K L H There is, for example, a fax letter dated 4 May 2006 from Mr. Shezad Sheikh of A. J.’s International Ltd. of Hong Kong to the effect that, due to the Article, a Hong Kong dinner to introduce ARY to the L M business community in Hong Kong had to be cancelled. N N O 150. Mr. Remedios rightly points out that the letter does not O expressly state that the Article had been accessed or downloaded by P Q Mr. Sheikh. But the tenor of the letter indicates that the contents of the Article had been sighted or accessed, if not by Mr. Sheikh personally, then P Q at least by the business persons whom he wished to invite. I think that on R S R the balance of probability I can draw such an inference. I note that there is no suggestion that Mr. Sheikh’s letter is a concoction. S T T U U V V