-24by the appellant in relation to the third respondent, the appeal must be dismissed against all of the respondents. (Geoffrey Ma) Chief Justice (Andrew Cheung) Permanent Judge (R A V Ribeiro) Permanent Judge (Joseph Fok) Permanent Judge (Robert French) Non-Permanent Judge Mr David Leung, SC, DPP, Mr Robert Lee, SADPP and Ms Kasmine Hui, SPP, of the Department of Justice, for the Appellant Mr David Boyton, instructed by T K Tsui & Co., for the 1st and 4th Respondents Mr Duncan Percy, instructed by Kenneth W Leung & Co., for the 2nd Respondent Mr James Tze, instructed by Raymond Luk & Co., for the 3rd Respondent