Lee Hsien Loong v Leong Sze Hian
[2021] SGHC 66
accessed the defamatory content. It is certainly arguable that, insofar as English
courts have attracted defamation cases with little or no connection with
England, possibly because of the attractiveness of English damages awards,
Jameel is a response to these concerns. There is no suggestion that concerns of
forum shopping apply on the instant facts.
70
The defendant suggests that the decision in Qingdao Bohai illustrates
wholesale acceptance by the Singapore courts of the reasoning in Jameel. I
decline to go so far, and make three observations on that case. First, Qingdao
Bohai was precisely a case where there were at least some concerns of forum
shopping. As the Court observed at [1] of Qingdao Bohai, that case concerned
12 articles posted on several foreign websites, and two articles containing
similar content which were published in Taiwan on 29 November 2013 in two
newspapers. The Court even went so far as to conclude that the first plaintiff in
that case did not even have a reputation in Singapore at the material time:
Qingdao Bohai at [49], [53], and [60]. Second, Jameel was, at best, a highly
secondary basis for rejecting the plaintiff’s claim. Significantly, the plaintiff
could not even establish that the first requirement for making out publication in
the context of online defamation, namely that the defendant had uploaded or
posted the defamatory material on the internet: at [121]. Jameel was thus not
central to the reasoning of the Court in Qingdao Bohai. Third, and critically, the
facts in Qingdao Bohai were somewhat extraordinary in that the Court
concluded that only one single third party had accessed the allegedly defamatory
material. This quite exceptional consideration is not reflected in, for example,
the present case, where (a) several dozen individuals had directly interfaced or
responded to the Post containing the linked Article (see [7] above); (b) the Post
was published on the defendant’s Facebook Wall, and would have been flagged
to his 5,000 Facebook friends and 149 Facebook followers; and (c) the Post was
38
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos