Case: 12-60264
Document: 00513162565
Page: 7
Date Filed: 08/20/2015
No. 12-60264
One of the committee members asked Bell why he had posted a new
version of the rap recording on YouTube, after school officials had discussed
with him his posting it on Facebook.
Bell gave a few (and somewhat
conflicting) explanations: the Facebook version was a raw copy, so he wanted
a finalized version on YouTube; the Facebook version was for his friends and
“people locally” to hear, whereas the YouTube version was for music labels to
hear; and he posted the YouTube version with a slideshow of pictures to help
better explain the subject matter of the recording (his Facebook version only
included a brief explanation of the backstory in the caption to the rap
recording).
Although Bell’s attorney, at one point, attempted to discuss the
misconduct of the coaches alleged in the rap recording, the school-board
attorney redirected the proceeding to its purpose: to resolve whether Bell
threatened, harassed, and intimidated the teachers; and, to decide whether his
suspension should be upheld.
In numerous instances, the school-board
attorney emphasized this purpose, noting Bell’s “comments made [in the
recording that] ‘you’ve f—ed with the wrong one / going to get a pistol down
your mouth / POW’[,] those are threats to a teacher”.
Bell contested the school-board attorney’s interpretation, responding:
“Well that ain’t really what I said”; and then provided what he described as the
written “original copy” of what had been recorded. (It is unclear from the
disciplinary-committee-hearing recording, or other parts of the summaryjudgment record, which copy Bell provided.) Bell explained he did not mean
he was going to shoot anyone, but that he was only “foreshadowing something
that might happen”.
(Emphasis added.)
But, he agreed that individuals
“outside the school setting” had made “certain statements” to his mother that
“‘put a pistol down your mouth’[,] that is a direct threat”.
7