Kiefel
Keane
Gleeson
CJ
J
J
6.
21
A focus on the intention of a putative publisher to communicate the matter
complained of is also said to explain the cases concerning whether occupiers are
publishers of defamatory statements affixed to their premises or structures by
unauthorised third parties, the appellants contend. These cases hold that, to be a
publisher, an occupier must have consented to, approved of, adopted or promoted
the continued presence of the statements, such that it can be said the occupier
accepted responsibility for their presence. The question of publication is therefore
determined by the courts by drawing an inference that the occupier intends to
communicate the matter, the appellants contend. No such deliberate act is present
in these appeals which would permit an inference of intention on the part of the
appellants to be drawn, it is submitted.
22
The appellants' contentions are not supported by authority and cannot be
accepted.
Publication and intention
23
In the law of defamation, harm is understood to be occasioned to a person's
reputation when a defamatory publication is made to a third party. Publication is
the actionable wrong. In Dow Jones & Co Inc v Gutnick18, publication was
described as a bilateral act by which the publisher makes the defamatory material
available and a third party has it available for their comprehension. Publication
may therefore be understood as the process by which a defamatory statement or
imputation is conveyed19.
24
In Trkulja v Google LLC20, it was said that "[i]n point of principle, the law
as to publication is tolerably clear". The judgment of Isaacs J in Webb v Bloch21
was cited for that proposition. In that case, Isaacs J drew upon texts to identify who
may be a publisher. Folkard22 described the word "published" as a technical term
in the law of libel. It is used, he said:
18
(2002) 210 CLR 575 at 600 [26].
19
Rolph, Defamation Law (2016) at 140 [8.20].
20
(2018) 263 CLR 149 at 163 [39].
21
(1928) 41 CLR 331 at 363-364.
22
Folkard, The Law of Slander and Libel, 5th ed (1891) at 439 (emphasis added by
Isaacs J).
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos