A A HCAL 122/2014 B C D IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST NO 122 OF 2014 E F B C D E _______________ F BETWEEN G SHAM WING KAN H and I COMMISSIONER OF POLICE J and K YEUNG CHING YIN 1st Interested Party K L CHAN SIN YING 2nd Interested Party L HUNG HIU HAN 3rd Interested Party CHAN SIU PING 4th Interested Party M N Applicant G H Respondent I J M N _______________ O O Before: Hon Au J in Court P Dates of Hearing: 4 November and 21 December 2015 P Q Dates of Supplemental Written Submissions: 24, 29 December 2015, and 20 May 2016 Q R Date of Judgment: 27 October 2017 R S T S JUDGMENT T U U V V