I-Admin (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Hong Ying Ting
[2020] SGCA 32
suffered so long as a defendant’s conscience has been impacted in the breach of
the obligation of confidentiality.
Threat to the interest
54
A question that follows is whether there is a threat to this wrongful loss
interest that warrants a more robust response by the law. The elements of breach
of confidence set out in Coco explicitly protect the wrongful gain interest.
Although there is often a degree of overlap, it may not always be the case that a
defendant’s conduct will affect both the wrongful gain and wrongful loss
interests. This is exemplified by the facts of the present appeal. It was not proven
that the respondents directly profited from their use of the appellant’s
confidential materials. However, this does not detract from the fact that the
respondents knowingly acquired and circulated these materials without consent.
As submitted by Mr Lee, such conduct would have affected the respondents’
conscience, invoking the wrongful loss interest, because it was known that the
relevant materials had been subject to an obligation of confidence.
55
This illustrates a significant and unchecked threat to the wrongful loss
interest. The vulnerability of this interest is magnified when considered against
the backdrop of advances in modern technology. It is now significantly easier
to access, copy and disseminate vast amounts of confidential information. This
can be done almost instantaneously, often without the knowledge of plaintiffs.
As in the present case, employees will often have access to large volumes of
confidential business material for the purposes of their employment. If at some
point they were to proceed to surreptitiously download this information for their
personal use or to start a competing business, employers are likely to be none
the wiser for a considerable time. It is nearly impossible in these situations to
safeguard information from all potential wrongdoing. The fragility of such
26
Sélectionner le paragraphe cible3
Se connecter à un paragraphe
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Ajouter à la table des matières