92 authorised team lead, on behalf of their legal counsel and P.W. 18 had downloaded the said email using official computer and took print out of the same using official printer and prepared certificate u/s 65 B of the Indian Evidence Act to authenticate the screen shot printout and identified the email printout of the information (exhibit 55) and the certificate u/s 65 B of the Indian Evidence Act to authenticate the screen shot printout (exhibit 56). On perusal of exhibit 52 this court finds it is the certified copy of the order which P.W. 4 had issued and had endorsed P.W. 11 for handling the official email id of CID, West Bengal for the period 01/8/2017 to 20/8/2017. P.W. 4 had stated this fact into his evidence as well and P.W. 18 had produced the certified as true copy of the same so P.W. 11 had right to access the official email of CID, West Begal for the period 01/8/2017 to 20/8/2017. It is clear from exhibit 55 that P.W. 18 had written email to the Competent Authority, www.pornhub.com and one reply came with a copy to email id Joyce.Carestia@mindgeek.com and this court finds this email id Joyce.Carestia@mindgeek.com from exhibit 7/6 as well and this exhibit 55 makes it clear before this court that Joyce.Carestia@mindgeek.com can reply to the emails as authorised team lead on behalf of www.pornhub.com. Exhibit 56 shows that it is a certificate u/s 65 B of the Indian Evidence Act issued by P.W. 18 to prove the authenticity of exhibit 55 and on perusal this court finds that it is proper. Now, on perusal of exhibit 7/6 this court finds that one Joyce Carestia had written it from email address Joyce.Carestia@mindgreek.com to the official email address of CID, West Bengal and it is clearly written that the user is listed as deleted but however information had been recovered from the logs and the videos were uploaded by the user Anibokshi from the IP : 47.15.15.236 . In this case from exhibit 7/6 this court finds that the “username” is “Anibokshi”, “email” is animeshbokshi18@gmail.com , “date_added” is “08/08/2015 “07/20/2017 11:34:56 GMT”, 16:50:43 “status” GMT”, is “last_login” “deleted” is and “status_reason” is “Self Deleted” and the URL which is mentioned in this exhibit is the same which is stated in the written complaint. Further other URL are also mentioned here. From this informations in exhibit 7/6 this court will take into notice some important informations like the email address animeshbokshi18@gmail.com , last login