CYRILLA: Global Digital Rights Law

CYRILLA: Global Digital Rights Law

- Bibliothèque
- S'identifier

Trié par

Date ajoutée

67 Relations, 61 Entités

Sélectionner le paragraphe cible3

● ● ●

Uwazi est développé par
CYRILLA: Global Digital Rights Law
Bibliothèque
Connexion

Info
67Relations

Graziani v. El Mercurio

Case Law

Astuces de recherche

Recherche de texte

Type something in the search box to get some results.

Table des matières

Aucune table des matières

Aucune description de Table des matières

Graziani v. El Mercurio

Case Law

Country

Chile

Country Location

Latitude: -33.37862595454361

Longitude: -70.68408456156871

Country Location (Lié Case Law): Chile

Decision Date: 21 janv. 2016

Case Status: Affaire Résolue

Case Outcome (Procedural)

Admissible

Case Outcome (Disposition)

Injunction or Order Granted

Keywords

Access to Information
Data Protection and Retention
Defamation / Reputation
Privacy
Right to be Forgotten

Judicial Body: Suprême (cour d'appel de dernière instance)

Court Name: Supreme Court of Chile

Case Number: 22243-2015

Case Summary: The Supreme Court of Chile applied the right to be forgotten doctrine and ordered the El Mercurio newspaper to delete all of the digital information regarding Mr. Graziani’s criminal case. Aldo Graziani filed a writ of protection and asked the Supreme Court to order El Mercurio newspaper to delete a 10-year-old news article about a criminal proceeding against him. He alleged that the news article violated his privacy and human dignity and impeded his social reintegration. The Court reasoned that because the article had been published a decade ago, the right to freedom of expression had to give way to the right of social integration and human dignity. In so doing it said that foreign jurisprudence had developed several criteria in order to balance these competing rights, one of them being the time factor. The Court said this does not mean that information will be deleted from every record but that access to that information will only be available from its original sources to those with real interest in knowing it and with a specific purpose- i.e. research purposes.

Case Significance: The decision contracts expression because it ordered El Mercurio to delete information on a matter of public interest, specifically the criminal investigation of sexual abuse. The dissenting opinion argued that the right to be forgotten should not prevail when the information to be deleted is of public/historic interest and involves behavior of a public figure.

The decision establishes a binding or persuasive precedent within its jurisdiction. The Supreme Court is Chile’s highest judicial organ.

Related Caselaw (self)

Fierro Caicedo v. Google Inc
Gloria v. Google y El Tiempo (Derecho al olvido)
Google Spain SL v. Agencia Española de Protección de Datos
Graziani v. El Mercurio

Related Law

Constitución

Source Name and URL: Global Freedom of Expression

Collection

Columbia

Date Updated: 3 juil. 2024

Documents principaux

Judgment (Spanish)
Spanish
Télécharger Vue

Pas de références

References are parts of this document related with other documents and entities.

Country1
- Country1
Related Case Law62
- Case Law62
Related Law1
- Law1
Aucune étiquettes3
- Case Law2
- Analysis1

Create Reference

Sélectionner le type de relation

Original Law Cited
Related Translation
Related Media Source
Country
Related Law
Related Regulations
Related Secondary Law
Related Amendments
Related Draft Amendments
Related Case Law
Related Analysis

Astuces de recherche

Ajouter des entités / documents

Astuces de recherche

Notifications

You're all caught up

New activity will show up here.