Issue 3A. Whether there is collection of data in HK? 7 . No collection. Applying the C-Aÿs reasoning in Eastweek Publisher, Google has no intention to identify any particular individual at all. There is collection of data，and Eastweek is not ap- X says the crawling of website by GL happen in HK.GL's plicable because name is collected. crawler needs to go to the website in HK, say Ming Pao to augment / rearrange such data. . Different from GL Different from PC and X Same as X Different from GL. But X has not expressly whether X agrees with the PC . Rcfercnce: sections 58 and 69 ol Appcllant\s reply statement Issue 3B. Whether there is processing or holding of data in HK? 8 . processing or holding of data in HK. X says the crawling of website by GL happen in HK. GL/s crawler needs to go to the website in HIC say Ming Pao, to rearrange such data. Same as PC Different from X Search results are tailored for HK internet users，and hence the search results is specifically arranged in HK. No. The search engine is installed outside of HK and there is no data centre in HK so there is no Same as GL Different from X Search results could be distributed via a .hk domain name, ie. www.google.com.hk. Different from GL and PC