— 24 — Chief Justice Li: 62. The Court unanimously dismisses the appeal. (Andrew Li) Chief Justice (R A V Ribeiro) Permanent Judge (Kemal Bokhary) Permanent Judge (Patrick Chan) Permanent Judge (Lord Millett) Non-Permanent Judge Mr Kevin KH Pun (instructed by Messrs Chak & Associates) for the appellant Mr RG Turnbull and Mr Hayson KS Tse (of the Department of Justice) for the respondent