The Oversight Board’s Bylaws provide for expedited review in “exceptional circumstances,
including when content could result in urgent real-world consequences,” and decisions are
binding on Meta (Charter, Art. 3, section 7.2; Bylaws, Art. 2, section 2.1.2). The expedited
process precludes the level of extensive research, external consultation or public comments
that would be undertaken in cases reviewed on ordinary timelines. The case is decided on the
information available to the Board at the time of deliberation and is decided by a five-member
panel without a full vote of the Board.
The Oversight Board selected this case and one other case, Hostages Kidnapped From Israel
(2023-050-FB-UA), because of the importance of freedom of expression in conflict
situations, which has been imperiled in the context of the Israel-Hamas conflict. Both cases
are representative of the types of appeals users in the region have been submitting to the
Board since the October 7 attacks and Israel’s subsequent military action. Both cases fall
within the Oversight Board’s crisis and conflict situations priority. Meta’s decisions in both
cases meet the standard of “urgent real-world consequences” to justify expedited review,
and accordingly the Board and Meta agreed to proceed under the Board’s expedited
procedures.
In its submissions to the Board, Meta recognized that “the decision on how to treat this
content is difficult and involves competing values and trade-offs,” welcoming the Board’s
input on this issue.
5. User Submissions
The author of the post stated in their appeal to the Board that they did not incite any violence,
but shared content showing the suffering of Palestinians, including children. The user added
that the removal was biased against the suffering of the Palestinians. The user was notified of
the Board’s review of their appeal.
6. Decision
While members of the Board have disagreements about Israel’s military response and its
justification, they unanimously agree on the importance of Meta respecting the right to
freedom of expression and other human rights of all those impacted by these events, and
their ability to communicate in this crisis.