professions, or by unions in areas with the same or similar economic activities or
geographical locations.
A union confederation or a coalition of union federations or union alliance is a
professional organization of workers that is established jointly and voluntarily by
union federations.
A national council of unions, which comprises of all union confederation(s), all
coalitions of union federation(s) or union alliances, is to be the only legally
unified representation of the entire union organization.
An employer federation refers to a professional organization, which is established
jointly and voluntarily by employer associations.
Shutting down the operation completely refers to a closing of an enterprise or
establishment according to the law and regulations in force.
Comments: Contrary to the aims of professional organizations as set out above “to cooperate
with one another to carry out activities or to develop their own procedural rules,” the
fundamental purpose of the right to form and join trade unions of one’s choice is to promote and
protect one’s economic and social interests,11 as recalled by the SRFAA.12 This is affirmed in
ILO Convention No. 87, whereby organizations are created “for furthering and defending the
interests of workers and employers”. Cooperation and the development of internal rules are
means by which workers and employers seek to achieve the ultimate aim of furthering their
interests.
OHCHR suggests the following reformulation of the first bullet point:
A professional organization refers to a voluntarily established group of workers or
employers through which workers and employers promote and defend their respective
interests. Toward this end, professional organizations develop their own procedural
rules, undertake activities and negotiate in regard to their demands. Professional
organizations may cooperate with one another to achieve specific professional objectives
or goals. By virtue of this law, a professional organization of workers is called a union,
whereas a professional organization of employers is called an association of employers.
OHCHR further recommends removing the second to last bullet point on a national council of
unions, as the rights and responsibilities of a national council of unions are not developed in the
draft law. The lack of clarity about the implications of being “the only legally unified
representation of the entire union organization” could be interpreted as an imposition on trade
unions, which would be contrary to ILO Convention No. 87.
CHAPTER 2
Fundamental rights to establish and to join a union or employer association
Article 5: All workers and employers have, without any distinction whatsoever, the
rights to form a union or an employer association of their own choice for the
exclusive purpose of study, research, training, promotion of interests, and protection
11
12
ICESCR, article 8, para. 1.
A/HRC/20/27, para. 53.
7