I-Admin (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Hong Ying Ting [2020] SGCA 32 customers. This excluded Lenovo Singapore for which the appellant created “LenovoSG.xls” as a specific database. (d) An email was sent by the first respondent to the third respondent’s employee Ms Vercilia Lim (“Ms Lim”) on 16 August 2011, attaching copies of the Payitem Bibles (“LenovoSG.xls” had been renamed as “SG payitem (2).xls”). (e) An email was sent by the second respondent to Ms Shen on 20 August 2011, attaching two files. These were “GIRO format.pdf”, which contained coding specifications from the appellant’s client OverseaChinese Banking Corporation Bank (“OCBC”) and “BankDiskOCBCSGONI.java”, which was a source code created by the appellant to generate a “bankdisk” file for OCBC. (f) An email was sent from the second respondent to the third respondent’s employee, Mr Errol Tan (“Mr Tan”), on 29 September 2011, attaching a copy of “cpf.xls” (see [10(b)] above). (g) An email was sent from the first respondent to Mr Tan, on 10 May 2012, attaching a copy of “RR to Li Lian.zip” (see [11(c)] above). 13 In June 2014, the appellant obtained a discovery order against the four respondents, compelling the disclosure of certain documents. The third respondent engaged a forensic expert to extract relevant files from the Dell Server, including any files deleted during the APO execution. On 15 July 2014, the first and second respondents reviewed the recovered files and saw that the “From Zaza” folder contained personal data from the appellant’s clients including HSBC Holdings plc (“HSBC”). HSBC was a client of ADP International Services BV (“ADP”), a global payroll service provider that had 7