Alexander-Theodotou v. Kounis
Case Law- Country
- Country Location
خط العرض: 52.32950805122076
خط الطول: -1.4047851562500706
- Country Location (مرتبط Case Law)
- United Kingdom
- Decision Date
- 16 أبريل 2019
- Case Status
- أُغلقت / إنتهت
- Case Outcome (Procedural)
- Dismissed
- Case Outcome (Disposition)
- اتخاذ تدابير إدارية / عقوبات إدارية لحماية حرية التعبير
- الحكم لصالح المدعى عليه
- حكم إعلانى / توضيحي
- قبول منح أمر قضائي / قرار إعدادي
- Keywords
- defamation
- Social Media
- Judicial Body
- المحكمة أول درجة
- Case Number
- HQ18M00041
- Case Summary
The High Court of Justice Queen’s Bench Division dismissed a libel action on the grounds that there existed no serious harm to the reputation of the claimants under the Defamation Act of 2013. Alexander-Theodotou brought the action in relation to a Facebook Post and webinars that allegedly implied her law firm failed to protect the best interests of her clients who were victims of a real-estate scandal in Cyrus, one of whom had committed suicide after losing his life savings in the scheme. Due to the publications, she claimed she had been personally exposed to “hate, contempt and ridicule,” and that she had lost clients resulting in serious financial losses. While the Court found the meaning of the Facebook post was “unquestionably defamatory,” evidence failed to prove serious harm. After assessing the gravity of the statements and the context of the publication, the Court concluded that not many of the readers of the Facebook post could have identified the claimant and those that could have, were already “dissatisfied ex-clients” or others who had a poor impression of the law firm prior to the post.
- Case Significance
The decision establishes a binding or persuasive precedent within its jurisdiction.