- 27 A
A
postpone the search until they could obtain a warrant.”
B
B
(paragraph 80)
C
(3)
Moreover, whether a cell phone search is justified further
depends on the types of crimes in a wide variety of
D
C
D
circumstances. (paragraph 799)
E
(4)
Even assuming that the police will act in good faith in
conducting the search of cell phones seized upon arrest, such
F
E
F
approach will inevitable create much uncertainty for the
G
police and increase the possibility of after-the-fact litigation
as to whether the search was properly done.
H
I
J
61.
Cromwell J’s approach therefore leaves much uncertainty as
to how to determine in the future whether a search of cell phones may or
G
H
I
J
may not be lawful.
K
L
K
62.
I can do no better than to adopt Karakatsanis J’s observation
L
at paragraph 105 of Fearon as to why the majority’s approach by
M
N
adopting the Conditions does not provide adequate protection of privacy
against a warrantless search:
“[105] The intensely personal and uniquely pervasive sphere of
privacy in our personal computers requires protection that is
clear, practical and effective. An overly complicated template,
such as the one proposed by the majority [ie, the Conditions],
does not ensure sufficient protection.
Only judicial
pre-authorization can provide the effective and impartial
balancing of the state’s law enforcement objectives with
O
P
Q
R
S
T
9
Where it was held that: ‘The law enforcement objectives served by searches incident to arrest
will generally be most compelling in the course of the investigation of crimes that involve, for
example, violence or threats of violence, or that in some other way put public safety at risk,
such as the robbery in this case, or serious property offences that involve readily disposable
property, or drug trafficking. Generally speaking, these types of crimes are most likely to
justify some limited search of a cell phone incident to arrest, given the law enforcement
objectives. Conversely, a search of a cell phone incident to arrest will generally not be
justified in relation to minor offences.’
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
U
V
V
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات