“(I am) serious in asking this: I want to organize ‘flash mob’ rape, would any brothers like to join? Flash Mob Rape [Jack Rolling] is a group formed by 5-6 boys, specifically intercepting single females. On each occasion, one of the guys will rape the female from behind and the others will render assistance and act as lookouts. After that, (we will have) her mouth gagged and hands tied before (we) flash (away) together …… (that’ll be) great! This modus operandi has its origin in South Africa, now (it) has spread to (one character indecipherable), I really hope (it) can be organized in Hong Kong. thread id: 1461292 posted by MasterMind on 2005-08-13 10:48:32” (“the First Message”) 6. After that, the Defendant added a sentence to his message: “Ha… 甘多人搞一個女仔重邊有得走! …… 有興趣 email 我: gigolo sar@yahoo.com” which can be translated to English as follows: “Ha …… the girl is handled by so many people and there’s no way (for her) to escape …… Those interested e-mail me at gigolo sar@yahoo.com ……” 7. The e-mail address “gigolo sar@yahoo.com” belonged to the Defendant. 8. Many people saw the First Message at the Message Board, and there were about 19 messages in response. About half of such responses showed that the respondents were disgusted and were resented by the Defendant’s act. Amongst those, one person with the code-name “vv” suggested to organize a “flash Jur (penis) cutting gang”, and invited “men of justice” to join. After that, some viewers responded expressing their wishes to join this “flash Jur cutting gang”. At 6:34 p.m. on 13 August 2005, the Defendant wrote at the Message Board 3

Select target paragraph3