-2- and FEVAWORKS SOLUTIONS LIMITED trading as ALIVE! MEDIA AND COMMUNICATIONS 1st Defendant / (2nd Respondent) ALIVE! MEDIA AND COMMUNICATIONS LIMITED 2nd Defendant / (3rd Respondent) ____________________ Before : Chief Justice Ma, Mr Justice Chan PJ, Mr Justice Ribeiro PJ, Mr Justice Litton NPJ and Mr Justice Gleeson NPJ Dates of Hearing: 5-6 June 2013 Date of Judgment : 4 July 2013 JUDGMENT Chief Justice Ma: 1. I agree with the judgment of Mr Justice Ribeiro PJ. The appeal should be dismissed. Mr Justice Chan PJ: 2. I agree with the judgment of Mr Justice Ribeiro PJ. Mr Justice Ribeiro PJ: 3. The respondents in this appeal are the providers, administrators and managers of a website which hosts one of the most popular internet discussion forums in Hong Kong. The appellants have sued them for libel in respect of defamatory statements posted by certain users of that forum. The defamatory