¶ 72
Defendant’s contention overlooks the fundamental difference between civil and
criminal law. “The civil action for a tort *** is commenced and maintained by the
injured person, and its primary purpose is to compensate for the damage suffered
at the expense of the wrongdoer.” Prosser and Keeton on the Law of Torts § 2, at 7
(W. Page Keeton et al. eds., 5th ed. 1984). The distinction between a tort and a
crime “lies in the interests affected and the remedy afforded by the law.” Id. “The
criminal law is concerned with the protection of interests common to the public at
large, as they are represented by the entity which we call the state; often it
accomplishes its ends by exacting a penalty from the wrongdoer.” Id. § 1, at 5.
¶ 73
Civil actions are inadequate. “[M]any civil remedies are not only insufficient or
unrealistic, but also counterintuitive in terms of their supposed redress or the harm
victims suffer.” Bustamante, supra, at 368. Scholars have explained as follows:
“Civil suits based on privacy violations are problematic. Most victims want
the offensive material removed and civil suits almost never succeed in removing
the images due to the sheer magnitude of dissemination. Highly publicized trials
often end in re-victimization. Civil litigation is expensive and time-consuming,
and many victims simply cannot afford it. It is difficult to identify and prove
who the perpetrator is for legal proceedings because it is so easy to
anonymously post and distribute revenge porn. Even when victims can prove
who the perpetrator is in court and win money damages, many defendants are
judgment-proof so victims cannot collect.
***
Further, a court order requiring a defendant or website to remove the images
would fail to remove the images from the web entirely, particularly as they
appear on numerous sites. Because most perpetrators are judgment-proof, and
injunctive relief may be difficult to obtain and would ultimately fail to remove
the images, civil suits are poor remedies. As perpetrators frequently have
nothing to lose, which is why they engage in this behavior in the first place,
civil suits do not deter revenge porn.” (Internal quotation marks omitted.)
Kitchen, supra, at 251-53.
Accord Souza, supra, at 111-15; Citron & Franks, supra, at 357-59.
- 22 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents